73

(SUPREME COURT.) HOLMES, OLIVER WENDELL; JR. Autograph Letter Signed, "OWHolmesJr," to journalist and lexicographer Carl Wilhelm Ernst

"OUR FOUNDERS . . . THOUGHT THEY WERE REPRODUCING THE ENGLISH CONSTITUTION" (SUPREME COURT.) HOLMES, OLIVER WENDELL; JR. Autograph Letter Signed, "OWHolmesJr," to journalist and lexicographer Carl Wilhelm Ernst ("Dear Mr. Ernst"), discussing the nature of the distinction between executive and legislative powers as employed in the constitutions of the U.S. and Great Britain. 3 pages, 8vo, written on a folded sheet, "Massachusetts / Supreme Judicial Court" stationery; marked dampstain affecting upper right of first and upper left of second pages (but text still legible), moderate uneven toning to second and third pages, folds. Boston, 9 September 1893

"I often have thought of the difficulties which might arise in trying to draw this line between Executive and Legislative functions. Of course, even if there is a principle of distinction the difference would be found to be one of degree as I am never tired of insisting that most differences are. I suspect history might have a good deal to do with the answer. . . .
". . . In Brackett v. Boston, 157 Mass 177, we had to deal with the St[atute] 1885 c. 266 which I doubt you remember provides as to 'the Executive powers of said city' (Boston)--but no attempt at distinction was made.
"You remember [Walter] Bagehot's remark in his 'English Constitution' that our founders, following Montesquieu and supposing the King to be the Executive of England, thought they were reproducing the English Constitution in sharply distinguishing the Executive and Legislative functions, ubi re vera the characteristic of the English Const'n is the fusion of the two. The true Executive being the leader of the House of Commons who goes out when he loses the majority."

  • Provenance:

    "I often have thought of the difficulties which might arise in trying to draw this line between Executive and Legislative functions. Of course, even if there is a principle of distinction the difference would be found to be one of degree as I am never tired of insisting that most differences are. I suspect history might have a good deal to do with the answer. . . .
    ". . . In Brackett v. Boston, 157 Mass 177, we had to deal with the St[atute] 1885 c. 266 which I doubt you remember provides as to 'the Executive powers of said city' (Boston)--but no attempt at distinction was made.
    "You remember [Walter] Bagehot's remark in his 'English Constitution' that our founders, following Montesquieu and supposing the King to be the Executive of England, thought they were reproducing the English Constitution in sharply distinguishing the Executive and Legislative functions, ubi re vera the characteristic of the English Const'n is the fusion of the two. The true Executive being the leader of the House of Commons who goes out when he loses the majority."
  • Condition:
    Please contact the Specialist for the auction to request a condition report.

    Condition reports and additional images are provided as a courtesy and should be used by you to aid in the formation of your own opinion regarding condition. All material is sold subject to Swann's standard Terms and Conditions of Sale as published in our catalogues and posted on our website, and include the following terms: (1) all property is sold "as-is"; and (2) works cannot be returned on the basis of condition.

Accepted Forms of Payment:

Money Order / Cashiers Check, Personal Check, Wire Transfer

Shipping

Upon request, Swann will facilitate the shipping of purchases to out-of-town buyers at an additional charge for packing, shipping and insurance, but will not be responsible for any loss, damage or delay resulting from the packing, handling and shipping thereof. Unless specific instructions are received, Swann is the sole judge of the method to be used for shipment. Packing and shipping costs will be noted on the invoice mailed to successful bidders after the sale, and are based on the actual costs involved. Be advised that a full commercial invoice must accompany any purchase shipped outside the US.

April 10, 2025 12:00 PM EDT
New York, NY, US

Swann Auction Galleries

You agree to pay a buyer’s premium, as outlined below, and any applicable taxes and shipping.
Buyer's Premium
$0 - $100,000:
27.00%
$100,001 - $1,000,000:
22.00%
$1,000,001+:
12.00%

View full terms and conditions

Bid Increments
From: To: Increments:
$0 $149 $10
$150 $499 $25
$500 $999 $50
$1,000 $1,999 $100
$2,000 $5,999 $200
$6,000 $9,999 $500
$10,000 $19,999 $1,000
$20,000 $49,999 $2,000
$50,000 $99,999 $5,000
$100,000 $199,999 $10,000
$200,000 $499,999 $20,000
$500,000 + $50,000